Excuse me, Qian Zhuangfei sacrificed?

There are many different claims about the sacrifice of Qian Zhuangfei.
. The place of sacrifice
1, Guizhou Province, Shatu Town, Liu Township, Liuchang Township
2, Houshan Township, Jinsha County, Guizhou
. The reason for sacrifice
1 , Air strike sacrifice
2, reconnaissance crossing the river line by the bandit attack
2, after being lost by local mobs

Said: "(Qian Zhuangfei) On March 31, when the Erdui Wulu River arrived in the midfielder of Xixian County, Guizhou, he was attacked and sacrificed by enemy planes." : "(Qian Zhuangfei) On March 31st, when Ersuku River, when he arrived in the bull field of Xixian County, Guizhou, he was killed because of an air attack on the enemy aircraft." : "On March 29, 34, 34, (Qian Zhuangfei) was sacrificed in the battle for the second time near Shatu Town, Xixian County, Guizhou." "沙 沙". It is said that they were sacrificed at the end of March in Xixian County, Guizhou. However, the "Double Hundred" candidate introduced: "(Qian Zhuangfei) participated in the Long March in October 1934, and was appointed Deputy Secretary -General of the General Political Department of the Red Army after the Zunyi meeting in 1935. In April of the same year, he was sacrificed in Jinsha County, Guizhou." Not only did time change, the location also changed. However, they are concentrated in Xixian County and Jinsha County in Guizhou Province.
The focus of the argument between the two states and Jinsha is: Whether Qian Zhuangfei has passed the Wujiang River (the river belongs to the river, and the river belongs to Jinsha). To this end, the Intelligence Department of the General Staff (three departments) held a special symposium in 1984. Qian Zhuangfei's subordinates at the time wearing mirror Yuan, He Junjun, Huang Huabing, and Zou Bizhao also formed two very different opinions. But why did the Party History Research Office of the Guizhou Provincial Party Committee of the Communist Party of China set the sacrifice place of Qian Zhuangfei in Sands in 2002? Let's take a look at what the Xi and Sands say each.

This said: The specific location is the unparalleled pit (unscrupulous pit) next to Songjiazhai, Liuchang Township, Xixi County. On April 1, 1935, the Kuomintang Air Force bombed Jiuzhuang Town of Xixian County and flew over the Liuchang Township. The forests along the river along the river are dense. After being lost, Qian Zhuangfei appeared in the area of ​​Customer Zhai and Songjiazhai on April 3 due to being sparse and sick. After losing contact with the large army due to severe illness, he lived in a mountain temple near Songjiazhai and was followed by the backbone of the local "Qingxiang Troupe" to grab the luggage. The Red Army claimed to be named Xia Shuyun. He found Chen Yushun, the Changchang Chang, a client, and said, "You can marijuana take away my luggage. After the troops, I don't agree. "After the local township chief, Song Zizhen of Qing Township, Song Zizhen learned of the matter, he conspired with his men Song Zhaorong, Fu Yincheng, Wang Xiangpei and other conspiracy to deceive the Red Army to the side of the pit and pushed it into a 40 -meter -deep pit. lethal. After liberation, Song Zizhen was executed by the government for leading a large number of people who killed the Red Army. At that time, Song Zhaorong, one of the murderers who participated in the killing of the Red Army, was sentenced to life imprisonment and released in 1980. The relevant personnel of the party history office in Xixian County had taken the photos of Qian Zhuangfei to identify Song. Song believes that the person of the photo was the Red Army who was pushed into a pit without a pit. According to the History of the Party History, the Party History of the Party concluded that Xia Shuyun was Qian Zhuangfei, so he treated a "Monthly Flying Martyrs Memorial Monument" on the side of the pit. The Party History Research Office of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of China believes that decades have passed, and the photos are identified by memory alone, and the evidence is not sufficient.

Sands said: The specific location is Yantianyan, Yankou Village, Houshan Township, Jinsha County. In January 1986, the Party History Office of the Communist Party of China and the Party History of the Party History of the Shati District Committee of the Communist Party of China jointly formed an investigation team. Dog Farm), Weng Gong, Houshan Township, on March 31, 1935, after all the troops of the Red Army had won all the south crossing the Wujiang River, a comrade of the Red Army followed the river crossing the river to the north bank of the Wujiang River alone. Walking in the direction. The Red Army was wearing a blue military uniform, carrying a yellow cloth bag and a small leather bag, holding a bag in his hand, and carrying a pistol (exposed outside). He is tall, with a long face, and accent. When the man walked to the Peng Guirong family, which was about Erhua, the north bank of the Wujiang River, and bought something from the Peng family. Because Peng Guirong did not understand him, he doubted that Peng ran back and ran out (Peng Guirong in 2006 told reporters that she made four poached eggs for the Red Army, and the Red Army took out a kitchen knife to give him a gift). The Red Army chased Chen Mu's house and bought eggs from Chen. Chen couldn't understand him and ran away. The Red Army left the Chen family and walked around the river. After walking less than a mile, after passing through the door of Li Congshan, the owner of the Landlord Landlord Liu family, he walked into the Li family and asked Li to bring the road. Li saw the red army single, with both pistols and parcels on his body. When Li Bao's Red Army walked to the Yantianyan (in the future of Yanshan Township) near the ladium, he stood on the top of Yantianyan, pretending to give the Red Army a route to the river. While Li was standing on the rock to concentrate on watching the path, Li's hand pushed the Red Army down the rock. This rock pen is steep, about 30 meters high. The Red Army fell to half rock and was hung by miscellaneous trees. Li stood on the roof and smashed the Red Army down the bottom of the rock with a random stones, and then Li walked down the rock to continue using the stone to kill the Red Army, and snatched the Red Army's pistols and all clothes. After Li Congshan returned home, his nephew Li Zhixiu met a silk clothes, a pair of gray pants, two wool clothes, and a pistol. Later, Li Congshan replaced the pistol to the Sha Tuzhen District member He Zhongpei and a horse. Half a year later, Li Congshan died of violence. A few days after Li Congshan murdered the Red Army a few days later, the local masses risked greatly to bury the Red Army's body on the spot. By August 1977, the water level in the library area of ​​Wujiang Power Station was rising. This place will be covered up. "". The joint investigation team determined that the Red Army martyr was Qian Zhuangfei. Therefore, Daxing Civil Engineering rebuilt the Qianzhuang Flying Tomb of 80 square meters in Zhangjiayukou, and built the "Qianzhuang Fei Martyrs Monument" covers an area of ​​about 200 square meters and steel bone cement structures in the east of Sha Tu Town. Essence

Stinsha also said that there are many problems, "blue military uniforms, yellow cloth bags, small leather bags, pistols, tall, long face, accents in the province" can indicate that the Red Army is Qian Zhuangfei? The biggest problem is that he can't do it with Zhou Enlai and Zou Bizhao. In 1940, Zhou Enlai received Qian Zhuangfei's family to Yan'an. Qian Zhuangfei's second son Qian Yiping recalled: "In Yangjialing, Zhou Enlai and Mother Deng called me to say, 'Your father was attacked by the enemy when he passed the Wuliang for the second time and launched a fierce battle. After the Kuomintang aircraft stopped bombarding After a while, the team gathered for a while, and I found that he was not around, so he ordered a team to go back to find ... Your dad sacrificed '. " Zou Bizhao, the deputy section chief of the second bureau of the Second Bureau of the Central Revolutionary Military Commission, said that after spending through the Wujiang River with Qian Zhuangfei, he turned over a high mountain (Dayatou) and was harassed by enemy planes. The Red Army issued it. The air strike signal, each of which was scattered and hidden, and after the air strike alert was lifted, they lost. During the Jiangxi period, only four of the Red Star Medal were awarded the Red Star Medal in the Second Bureau of the Chinese Revolutionary Military Commission. The deciphering master Zou Bizhao was one of them. Compared with non -technical cadres such as Dai Jingyuan, Zou Bizhao's memories were more reliable. That is to say, no matter Zhou Enlai or Zou Bizhao, it is determined that Qian Zhuangfei crossed the Wujiang River to avoid the missing air strike. The money is not possible to sacrifice in Sands.
In October 1934, the Central Red Army began the Long March. In addition to the field army, the CIA CIA CIA CIA of the Communist Party of China, the Code of the CIA of the Central Revolutionary Military Commission is the Red Star Column. The fourth team followed Mao Zedong, Zhou Enlai, Zhu De and other actions to do intelligence guarantee for the Party Central Committee and the Central Revolutionary Military Commission.长征途中，为了确保每天24小时工作不停顿，第四分队采取歇与不歇两梯队工作制，即把人员分成两个梯队，前面一个梯队行军时，后面一个梯队工作；后面一个梯队行军时， The first echelon works. The two echelons work alternately and march alternately. Although Qian Zhuangfei was appointed as the Deputy Secretary -General of the Political Department of the Red Army after the meeting, he was still in the Second Bureau of the Military Commission.
The night on March 29, 1935, the third regiment of the first division of the Red One Army broke through the Wujiang Ferry in Datang Ferry, Houshan Township, Jinsha County. In the early morning of the morning, the Central Revolutionary Military Commission issued an order to cross the Wujiang River. The limitation of the Military Commission's column was completed before 10 am on the 31st. The cadre regiment was a guard alert. On the 30th, the Military Commission's column to the camp of the area around Houshan Township; on the 31st, through the ladder rock and Datang Ferry, the flowing bridge to the stream of the stream of Xixian County gathered the camping camp. At noon on April 1st, the Kuomintang Air Force reconnaissance aircraft went to Xunchang Township, Lulu Township, and Jiuzhuang Town of Xixian County. Essence If Qian Zhuangfei avoids the missing air strikes, it will only be in Liuchang Township and Jiuzhuang Town of Xixian County. It is impossible to avoid the air strike and then go back to Wushan Township to be killed by gangsters. Even if the Military Commission collaborated on the morning of the 31st, the Red Army Cadre Regiment and the Red Five Army had not yet crossed the river. There are Red Army near the ferry. How can senior cadres such as Qian Zhuangfei fall behind and be killed by thugs?

. As for the Party History Research Office of the Guizhou Provincial Party Committee, Qian Zhuangfei made Qian Zhuangfei on April 1, 1935 in Yankou Village, Houshan Township, Jinsha County. Work should be used for economic. " Since Xi said that it has been rejected by the relevant central departments, only Jinsha said. Moreover, there are still heavyweights to support Sands. The former staff of the former Military Commission wearing Jingyuan supported Jinsha. He only retreated from the three ministers of the General Staff in December 1982. The opinion of the old minister's opinion at the Symposium on the three organizations in 1984 was self -evident on the conclusion of the conclusion. The memories of the former Military Commission's artillery deputy political commissar Ouyang Yi also said that Qian Zhuangfei was sacrificed after being tied up by local bandits on the north bank of the north bank of Wujiang.
In April 2002, after the conclusion of Qianzhuang Township, Qianzhuang Township was concluded, Houshan Township received the first benefit of 10.5 million yuan in Guizhou Province, and more than 5 million supporting funds in the city and counties repaired a one of them. 20 kilometers long out of the mountain road. Then the Ministry of National Security allocated special funds to build Qian Zhuangfei Martyrs Cemetery and Qian Zhuangfei Martyrs Deeds Exhibition Room. The Qianzhuang Flying Martyrs' Cemetery and Deeds Exhibition Room in Houshan Township are the "National Security Education Base" and "Guizhou Patriotic Education Base" named by the Ministry of National Security, the Guizhou Provincial Party Committee, and the Guizhou Provincial People's Government. It is one of the patriotic education bases of 16 key construction and "changing Chen Baizhan" determined by the Guizhou Provincial Party Committee's Propaganda Department. It is also one of the 50 red tourism spots in the province. The number of visitors from 2005 to 2007 reached more than 200,000.

Is for the sacrifice of Qian Zhuangfei, the sacrifice of air strikes was not established, because if it was killed by the Kuomintang Air Force, there would be no comrades who killed him to collect corpses and report to superior. It is impossible for Zhou Enlai to know. After Zhou Enlai knew that Qian Zhuangfei had disappeared, he ordered the Red Five Legion behind the Hall of the Hall of the Central Revolutionary Military Commission to find it. Ouyang Yi, the director of the Political Defense Bureau of the Red Five Army, personally led the team back to the north bank of the Wujiang River to find it.
The survey of the River Route by bandits was even more absurd. After Qian Zhuangfei arrived in the Central Soviet Area, he served as Minister of the Investigation Department of the Political and Defense Department of the Republic of the Soviet Republic of China, the Director of Political Defense of the Military Military Military, the Second Director of the Second Bureau of the Chinese Revolutionary Military Commission, and deputy director of the second game. Work. At that time, the military cadres who served as a former rivalry reconnaissance task would not be sent, let alone a military -level technical cadre such as Qian Zhuangfei, and let him go alone to reconcile. Rich.
"The Party History Expo" published the article "Mystery of Qian Zhuangfei Missing" in the 9th issue of 2007. The author Wang Chunxiao believes that Qian Zhuangfei may sacrifice in the afternoon of April 1, 1935 to sacrifice in Jiuzhuang, the Kuomintang Air Force, Jiuduzhuang In the bombing of the town. When the Kuomintang Air Force came to reconnaissance in the morning, Qian Zhuangfei hid the air strike and lost the second bureau of the Military Commission. Later, he marched with the Fifth Army of the Army to Jiuzhuang Town, Xixian County. Because no one knew Qian Zhuangfei, he only knew that he was the head of the head. Therefore, Qian Zhuangfei was buried alone after sacrificing, and the remaining martyrs were buried in a tomb. This says that there is a certain reason, but the author has not seen the memories of Ouyang Yi, the director of the Political Defense Bureau of the Red Five Army. Essence

The Qian Zhuangfei was neither rebelled nor captured after the disappearance of the disappearance. Therefore, the reason for the sacrifice of Qian Zhuangfei is basically the same: the argument is basically the same: after being lost, he was killed by the mobs of Sands or the Study. The problem is that Jinsha said that it was basically impossible. The "Xia Shiyun" of Xi Hui was logical, but the evidence was not enough. Therefore, I think that in April 1935, Qian Zhuangfei was killed by thugs after falling behind in Jinsha and Xi in Guizhou.